AI and how I write
There have been enough articles about AI use among writers that I felt a need to stake a position. Bottom line: I support minimal use (assistive) to polish an otherwise wholly human creation. I think that once all the shouting about AI has died down, this is the reasonable position. Novels are about human connection. Human creation.
According to recent news:
A federal judge granted final approval to Anthropic’s historic $1.5 billion class-action copyright settlement. The case centered on allegations that the AI company stored millions of pirated books in a central library to build its Claude AI models. Eligible authors and publishers receive roughly $3,000 per qualifying title.
Anthropic acquired 500,000 titles from various pirate sites, as I understand it. My second published novel Bellicose was one of those titles. With the judge's signature, payments should be going out in the next year. This was the largest infringement case in history. So I guess that means I'm a part of history now. There's an assertion that you'll sound like AI because your book was used to train, but that's not how AI detectors work. (But it's annoying when I'm told by an AI-detector a book I wrote 15 years ago is likely AI.)
Craig Martelle announced dozens of his books were also caught up in the infringement. That that doesn't mean his works will also have the odor of AI. But I know from listening to him that he's as far from using AI to generate as east is to west.
Recently, the Horror Writer's Association unseated (and I think banned) a trustee for asserting the premise that one should not witch hunt those who use AI. This follows a talk I attended three years ago when AI first reared its head. But the witch hunt was from the pro-AI attacking someone for endorsing the Screen Writer's Guild policy on generative AI. Cancel culture exists on both sides.
I've sat in on the Facebook Groups where authors are boastful in their use of AI to generate and publish dozens of books. One claims he can write a new book in 75 minutes. But, let's face it. he's not. The US Copyright Office has a de minimis rule that limits how much AI can be in a work to receive credit. Amazon has a rule, too.
I used to have an article arguing AI use was like white water rapid levels. The more you used it, the better you had to be to understand it. I can see using AI to translate your novel into a foreign language and then hiring a native editor to proofread it. The book would never have been published in that language otherwise. But at least the writer of the original work was fully human.
My use of AI has remained in the USCO's de minimis use. One a five-scale of AI use (1 is Craig-against and 5 is full-generative), I am a 2. I think it's fine for assistance because I already created the work.
- My Postal Marine novels were too violent—more R than PG13 when I prefer PG13. AI helped me identify the concerning areas. I re-wrote those areas.
- Early reviews complained about line editing. So I used Claude to help line edit. I'm too early in my career to hire a professional, which is my preference.
- My alpha readers noticed a few continuity errors (mostly with the Strand series). I used Claude that helped me find more—which (I corrected).
- AI to help outline and line-edit blog posts. But I wrote the post.
There are some readers, and writers, who will find de minimis too much. I respect that. But I've also read about editors who used AI to line edit novels—and the author paid the social price. Book cover artists use Photoshop's AI tool to tweak a cover they drew.
Cory Doctorow asserts that centaurs are skilled, experienced workers who use AI on their own terms, applying expert judgment to improve quality. That requires a bit of an open mind in the debate when you're the expert.
I created Verkilo—a desktop novel writing application for series authors—because I wanted better solution than Scrivener that was local. After building it, I tried Obsidian (and advocate it), but I wanted the more "all-in-one" experience I got with Verkilo.
Verkilo has some AI integration. It helps with line editing. It can help as a continuity manager. Not as well as a human, but well enough to suit my needs. AI is not integrated into the application, it's an option.
As a society, the West (or at least the US) has found any number of causes to fan to religious wars and cause division. Use of AI is one of them. I've chosen not to grab a pitchfork because I know eventually the pitchfork is in another's hands.
AI isn't going away. We need the right balance so that it supports human creativity without replacing—or displacing it. We need a healthy debate to find that balance.
