America Needs Trains, not Planes
The TV series Landman is a modern Western. Excellently written, directed and acted. But a subtle message throughout is the energy crunch that is inevitably coming our way. I remember as kid and teen being constantly told we are ten years from peak oil. In the late 1990s, we would hit peak in 2004. But the peak is still just over the horizon—2030s now.
Rather than cry foul, I recognize that our means to extract oil has gotten better over the past half century (and longer). All the easy oil has been extracted by our forefathers. Just like all the easy coal, iron, etc. has been extracted. It only gets harder.
We keep being told that "country X has vast oil reserves." But all oil is not oil. It's a play on a stereotype. Venezulan oil is thick sludge, not the sweet oil we need for daily needs. Over the past 100 years, the cost to extract a barrel of oil went from 1:100 (oil barrels spent to oil barrels extracted) to 1:15. When that gets to 1:1, then it's no longer economically sound to extract the oil. By then, we need to be somewhere.
Rail is the Answer. Let's face it, air travel will get more expensive. Road travel, too. Diesel was $5-gallon when we were driving through North Carolina a few weeks ago. That lends itself to biofuel, but that's costly and limited. Trains will handle more shorter trips. Flying will still exist for important long journeys, but it will feel more like a special treat than an everyday option.
I love trains. I lived in Germany for three years and could get from city to city by hopping a train. Heavily subsidized by a government with a land mass the size of New Mexico or Montana. It is less energy efficient as air travel, but more flexible in its energy source. The extension cord for an aircraft is a little hard to manage.
There's a lot of talk about high-speed rail. A perpetual boondoggle. We don't need it, especially if we are approaching reduced energy availability.
When Rail Travel was King. Through the 19th Century, rail travel came into its own. But you had to have a water stop every 10 miles to avoid boiler explosions. Imagine, 30 minutes of travel to cover 10 miles (at 25MPH), then 30 minutes to refuel. And people complain about Tesla Supercharger waits. You'd cover 240 miles a day. Better than a horse. A little less than a cross-country day's drive with rest-stops.
At the peak of US passenger rail travel in the 1920s, standard long-distance trains offered a comfortable and elegant experience for millions of Americans. About what you have on Amtrak today. Trains were fast (50–70 mph) and reliable. The connecting cities across the country. A cross-country trip from New York to California took about four days. Rail was the main way most people traveled long distances before cars and planes took over.
We have the most of the infrastructure. Today, US passenger rail travel is limited and slow compared to its peak. Amtrak serves mostly Northeast Corridor routes efficiently while long-distance trains are infrequent, often delayed, and primarily used for scenic leisure trips rather than everyday transportation. But we have 140,000 miles of railway today; three times our Interstate highways.
What do we need? Build a nationwide network of reliable electric passenger trains, with frequent daily service connecting major cities and towns. They only need to travel about 70 mph. Focus on comfort, on-time performance, and affordability to restore easy inter-city travel.
Many existing routes could be upgraded for passenger service by adding electrification, passing sidings, modern signaling, and new or restored stations. This would allow reliable 60 to 79 mph service on existing rights-of-way without building entirely new high-speed lines everywhere. It's cheaper and faster to implement than starting from scratch, though it still requires major investment in track upgrades and shared-use agreements with freight railroads. Northeast Corridor-style improvements could spread gradually.
I bought The Great Railroad Revolution to explore the full history of American rail travel in the 19th and 20th Centuries. Call it novel research.
